Both Makita and Dewalt are the most reliable brands available for air compressors. And if you are looking for a compressor that is powerful, compact, and portable then these Makita MAC5200 and Dewalt D55146 are the perfect options available in the market.
And in this article, we have compared both Makita Mac5200 vs Dewalt D55146 with their similarities and differences. So that you can easily understand which one to choose and why.
Both these air compressors are super portable and powerful which makes them more convenient to use for multiple operations. So if you are a remodeler or a Handyman then these can be the best options available for you.
So without any further delay, let’s get straight into it.
Table of Contents
Dewalt D55146 vs Makita Mac5200 Comparison
| SPECIFICATIONS | Dewalt D55146 | Makita Mac5200 |
|---|---|---|
| Pump Type | Oil-Free | Oil-Lubricated |
| Horsepower | 1.6 HP | 3.0 HP |
| Maximum Operating Pressure | 225 PSI | 140 PSI |
| Construction Type | Compact Design | Roll-Cage Design |
| CFM Rating | 5 CFM at 90 PSI | 6.5 CFM at 90 PSI |
| Tank Size | 4.5 Gallons | 5.2 Gallons |
| Portability | Equipped with rubber wheels with a handle | Equipped with portable wheels |
| Noise Level | Less Noisy | Noisier |
| Warranty | Only 1 Year of warranty | 1 Year of warranty with 30 Days of Replacement Policy |
| Check Latest Price | Check Latest Price |
Makita MAC5200 and Dewalt D55146 Air Compressor Reviews
Makita MAC5200 3.0 HP Big Bore Air Compressor
Makita is one of the most trustworthy brands for air compressors because Makita provides one year of comprehensive warranty along with a 30 day of replacement policy. Which creat a major difference from most of the other brands.
This air compressor has a super-powerful oil-lubricated 3 HP of motor which is equipped with a big bore engineered cylinder and piston which makes it efficient enough for higher outputs. And the cast-iron build makes it durable enough for long-lasting operations.
Because of this powerful motor, this air compressor can deliver 6.5 CFM at 90 PSI and 6.9 CFM at 40 PSI. Apart from these ratings, this air compressor can be operated with a maximum operating pressure of 140 PSI.
This air compressor is also equipped with a large air tank with a capacity of 5.2 gallons which is designed to withstand high pressure. And the best part is that the whole tank is built with cast iron to provide a longer lifespan.
The large tank with a powerful motor makes the compressor heavy and bulky but because of the portable wheels with a foldable handle, it can be easily transported.
With the help of multiple gauges with a regulator, you can easily control the compressor. Apart from that, it is also equipped with a twin air output valve, so you can easily use two air tools at a time.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Powerful and efficient pump.
- Deliver high CFM.
- Highly durable and long-lasting.
- Portable air compressor.
- Large tank capacity.
- A replacement warranty is available.
- Roll cage design for extra protection.
Cons
- The maximum operating pressure is quite low.
- A bit noisier.
- Bulkley compressor.
- The pump requires frequent maintenance.
Why should you buy this?
So if you want a compressor that can deliver high CFM at a certain pressure range with a decent size tank for medium to heavy-duty operations then this air compressor is the perfect option available for you.
Read More: Makita Mac2400 Vs Mac5200
Read More: Rolair VT25Big vs Makita Mac5200
Read More: Best Makita Air Compressor
DEWALT Air Compressor 225-PSI Max, 4-1/2 Gallon (D55146)
Dewalt is known for its product quality and efficiency and this air compressor is equipped with a 1.6 HP of oil-free pump. And because of the oil-free design, it requires less maintenance and is also less efficient as compared to an oil-lubricated pump.
This compressor can be operated with the maximum air pressure of 225 PSI which is quite higher compared to other air compressors but it creates only 78 dB of noise which is manageable.
This air compressor can deliver high 5.0 SCFM at 90 PSI which is enough for most air tools but I suggest that you should choose Makita 5200 if you have heavy-duty tasks.
A 4.5 gallon of air tank is also available with this compressor which is built with high-quality material but the capacity is less as compared to Makita Mac5200 so it can store less amount of air.
This air compressor is also equipped with rubber wheels with a foldable handle so you can easily carry this compressor wherever you want.
The control panel has dual pressure gauges with a regulator which helps to control the right pressure levels and dual air output valves are also available to operate multiple air tools at a time.
Dewalt provides 1 year of comprehensive warranty on all their compressors. So this air compressor also comes with 1 year of complete warranty but any replacement warranty is not available.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Pumps require less maintenance.
- The maximum operating pressure is high.
- Portable and easy to use.
- Durable and long-lasting.
- Low noise level.
- Good for light to medium-duty operations.
Cons
- Less tank size.
- Deliver lower CFM.
- Less powerful pump as compared to Mac5200.
- Not recommended for heavy-duty operations.
Why should you buy this?
This air compressor has a pump that requires less maintenance but is also less powerful. So if the given CFM rating and tank size are good enough to operate your required air tools then go with this compressor. It’s also much more affordable than that.
Read More: Best Dewalt Portable Air Compressor
Differences Between Makita Mac5200 and Dewalt D55146
Pump Type with Horsepower
Makita Mac5200 air compressor is equipped with an oil-lubricated pump which required frequent maintenance but these are much more efficient than an oil-free pump. But on the other hand, Dewalt D55146 comes with an oil-free motor so it’s easy to maintain and produces less noise.
And if I talk about the power of those pumps then the Makita compressor has a 3.0 HP of powerful pump which can compress the air faster and is known for quick recovery. But the Dewalt compressor comes with a 1.6 HP of motor which is quite less compared to that.
PSI and CFM Ratings
Dewalt air compressor can be operated with a maximum operating pressure of 225 PSI and Makita Mac5200 can be operated with a max pressure of 140 PSI. So because of the higher PSI rating, Dewalt D55146 is used for a wide range of applications.
CFM is more important than maximum operating PSI. Because of the powerful motor on the Makita Mac5200 compressor, it can deliver 6.5 CFM at 90 PSI. And on the other hand, Dewalt D55146 can deliver 5.0 CFM at 90 PSI. So the conclusion is, with the Makita compressor, we can perform more heavy-duty tasks.
Tank Size
An air tank is used to store compressed air. So if there is more compressed air in the tank then you can operate the air tool for a long time. So every time the large tank has an advantage.
Among those compressors, Makita Mac5200 has a larger tank capacity of 5.2 gallons with cast-iron built which enhances its durability. And Dewalt D55146 has a little lower capacity of 4.5 gallons which makes it more compact and lightweight.
Noise Levels
Because the powerful motor with a large tank on Makita Mac5200 creates more noise as compared to Dewalt D55146 which has a low horsepower motor with a small tank.
Compressor Warranty
Makita provides 1 year of comprehensive warranty on the product with additional 30 days of replacement warranty. But Dewalt has no replacement policy it has only 1 year of comprehensive warranty on the product.
Price
Both compressors have a major price difference. So if you have a low budget then go with Dewalt D55146 but Makita Mac5200 is more powerful and good for those who have a high budget.
Similarities Between Makita Mac5200 and Dewalt D55146
Portability
Both the compressors are equipped with rubber wheels with foldable handles. So you can easily carry this compressor wherever you want.
Easy to Use
Both the compressors have dual pressure gauges with a regulator which helps to maintain the right pressure levels and twin air output valves are also available so you can use dual air tools at a time to increase your productivity.
Customer Reviews
Both compressors are durable and good for long-lasting performance. So both the compressor get amazing customer reviews.
FAQs for Mac5200 vs D55146
1. Which is more compact and produces less noise between Makita Mac5200 vs Dewalt D55146?
Of these two compressors, Makita Mac5200 has a larger tank which makes the compressor Bulkley and the powerful motor creates more noise but Dewalt D55146 is equipped with a smaller tank with a less powerful compressor which makes the compressor much more portable and silent than Makita Mac5200.
2. Which air compressor is more powerful Makita Mac5200 or Dewalt D55146?
Makita has 3 HP of powerful pump which can deliver 6.5 CFM at 90 PSI but Dewalt D55146 has 1.6 HP of pump which can deliver 5.0 CFM at 90 PSI.
Conclusion: Dewalt D55146 and Makita Mac5200
So after comparing both air compressors between Makita Mac5200 vs Dewalt D55146 we have concluded that if you want a compact design compressor then go with Dewalt D55146 and if you want a powerful compressor then go with Makita Mac5200.
So Which air compressor can fulfill your requirements? Let me know in the comment box.
So guys If you liked this post don’t forget to share.
By the way, thanks for visiting.
